Home N2O Monitoring Highlights Potential for GHG Emissions Reduction

N2O Monitoring Highlights Potential for GHG Emissions Reduction

Spernal, Severn Trent’s Resource Recovery and Innovation Centre

Severn Trent is the UK’s second biggest water company, serving 4.4 million private and business customers in England and Wales. Spernal STW is a medium sized sewage treatment works in Warwickshire with a dry weather flow capacity of 27,760 m3/day. With a discharge consent on ammonia, and resulting focus on nitrification in nitrogen treatment, it is a typical site for the UK and other parts of the world.

Spernal Sewage Treatment Works serves as Severn Trent’s “Urban Strategy Demonstration Site”, where emerging technologies that are compatible with a low energy, circular economy approach are being evaluated. As such, it was Severn Trent’s first site to be equipped with dissolved nitrous oxide sensors. The goal of installing the sensors was to gain a better understanding of the site’s scope 1 climate impact and the potential for reducing emission by means of process optimizations. While this study shows a short period of data collection, long term monitoring is implemented to fully understand GHG emissions and triggers for N2O formation.

Severn Trent

Case Study: Nitrous Oxide Monitoring in a Typical Nitrifying Activated Sludge Process

N2O Monitoring in the Activated Sludge Tanks

The activated sludge lanes at Spernal are divided into a short anoxic zone followed by 3-pass aerated zones (Fig. 1), where most of the nitrification takes place. Severn Trent implemented N2O monitoring in the aerated part of the sludge tanks. The sensors are maintained as part of the site’s regular measuring routine. The two N2O sensors are approx. 25% and 50% into the aerated zone, collocated with DO sensors (Fig. 1). These locations provide a representative value for the emissions of a whole aeration zone. Depending on the layout of the zones and mode of aeration used, a period of scouting with one sensor (while keeping the other in position as reference can be advantageous.

Results from One Month's Data Collection

The data discussed here is based on one month’s data collection and is shown in Figure 2. By comparing the measured parameters, it can be concluded that N2O formation is mainly dependent on ammonium loading. During the first 17 days, N2O concentrations were high in both passes, with the highest values in pass 2. This is likely due to an accumulation of nitrites, which coupled with local zones of low oxygen can trigger nitrifier denitrification to produce N2O.

From day 17 onward there is a significant drop in the mean inlet NH4 concentration. Subsequently, N2O concentrations in pass 1 are almost negligible, with lower N2O concentrations in pass 2 as well. With a lower load, the ammonium-based aeration controller safely moves the ammonium load toward the second pass. This results in a slower ammonium turnover and reduced nitrite accumulation. This combination leads to a lower N2O production. The load change is also reflected in the reduced effluent ammonium concentrations (Fig. 2).

Figure 1: Activated Sludge Tank
Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions

After analyzing the data, two potential methods for reducing N2O emissions where identified: The first is to improve load balancing to reduce overloading where possible, while the second is to distribute NH4
turnover throughout the lane by using aeration cascading that relies on N2O sensor input. Continuous monitoring of N2O will help quantify the full extent of scope 1 N2O emissions from this site and validate any
mitigation measures that may be trialed.

Severn Trent has ambitious plans to be at the forefront of the UK Water Sector’s Net Zero initiative and the circular economy. This includes investments in energy savings and energy production as well as advanced nutrient recovery – all while reducing the carbon footprint of their operations. With the implementation of real-time N2O monitoring, Severn Trent is now gathering in-depth knowledge and understanding of their sites’ performance and can realize opportunities to reduce greenhouse gases while optimizing the use of energy and resources to the benefit of their customers and the environment.

Figure 2: Key parameters of performance for the activated sludge tank
What to kN2Ow about N2O emissions?
N2O (nitrous oxide) is a potent greenhouse gas (GHG), with a global warming potential that is 273 times higher than that of carbon dioxide. Wastewater treatment plants are a significant source of N2O emissions, as sludge bacteria create N2O when experiencing sub-ideal conditions. High ammonia loading, accumulation of nitrite and low O2 levels are the most common trigger conditions during nitrification.
Studies have shown that N2O can make up 50-90% of a single treatment plants’ GHG emissions. On a global scale, total GHG emissions from wastewater treatment plants are considered as significant as those from air traffic. Reducing the N2O emissions at wastewater treatment facilities is therefore a sustainability target of highest importance for all modern water utilities.

Tech Notes & References

Tech Notes
N2O Sensor
N2O sensor matches 91% of measured off-gas emissions

Case Study: Full-scale comparison of N2O emissions determined by liquid sensors and off-gas measurement

Identifying N2O at the Flensburg wastewater treatment plant

The investment costs had initially deterred us somewhat. However ...

Tech Notes
N2O Monitoring Highlights Potential for GHG Emissions Reduction

Learn about the results from N2O monitoring in the activated sludge tanks at Severn Trent’s Spernal sewage treatment plant

Characterizing N2O emissions from WWTPs figure 3
Tech Notes
Characterizing N2O emissions from WWTPs

A study of three very different WWTPs in Denmark: Bjergmarken (125,000 PE), Holbæk (60,000 PE), and Hvalsø (11,570 PE)

N2O Mechanisms
Tech Notes
National N2O mapping and reduction of N2O-emission through advanced online-control

Based on data from Danish WWTPs through advanced online-control.

Sensor Nivå_1400x800
Tech Notes References
N2O Sensor Controls Emissions from Deammonification Processes

Learn how the water utility Aquafin controls emissions from deammonification processes using the the N2O Wastewater Sensor

Tech Notes
Direct Effect of Activated Sludge Concentration on N2O Emission and CO2-equivalents at Full-scale

Significant 3-fold increase in IPCC2019 wastewater N2O emission factor supported by Danish studies.

Figur 1_featured_700x400
Tech Notes References
Positioning of the N2O Wastewater Sensor

A case study from Kralingseveer WWTP in the Netherlands explores the influence of sensor placement.

Operational experience with the N2O Wastewater Controller

WWTP Pforzheim uses an N2O sensor to determine the formation rate of nitrous oxide in the denitrification and the nitrification zone

Recirculation setup frederikshavn_1400x800
Frederikshavn Water Utility

Frederikshavn Water Utility contacted Unisense Environment for assistance in determining the actual N2O derived CO2 footprint

Ejby Mølle bassin_1400x800
N2O Monitoring Puts VCS Denmark at the Technological Forefront

VCS Denmark, one of the largest and oldest water and wastewater companies in Denmark, is actively committed to resource optimization

Controller Biofos_1400x800
Tech Notes
N2O Emissions from Danish WWTPs – a two year monitoring project

The available data show that the nitrous oxide emission varies in time and between wastewater treatment plants.

Fig. 1_1400x800
Tech Notes
Nitrous Oxide Emissions from Trickling Filters

Information regarding N2O emissions from trickling filters is limited, partly caused by the difficulties in capturing off-gases.

IPCC 2019 report_1400x800
Tech Notes
IPCC Greenhouse Emission Factors

Significant 3-fold increase in IPCC2019 wastewater N2O emission factor supported by Danish studies.

Carbon Dosage Control
Tech Notes
A tool for Carbon Dosage Control

Monitor the N2O concentration in the liquid and use N2O as a control parameter for carbon dosage in the denitrification process.